Bone Stress Injury, Tendon Pain or a Niggle? How Runners Can Tell
The short answer: A niggle usually eases as you warm up. A bone stress injury usually does the opposite: a pinpoint spot on the bone that hurts more the longer you run and stays sore at rest. If your pain fits the second pattern, stop running and get it assessed rather than testing it with another long run.
- Three different things get called ‘runner’s niggles’: plain overload, tendon pain and bone stress. They behave differently and need different plans.
- Bone pain is usually a small, pressable spot that gets worse as the run goes on and lingers afterwards.
- Recent research links bone stress injuries to menstrual disruption, low energy intake and a previous bone stress injury, not just mileage.
- A good comeback is built on criteria, not a calendar. The popular ‘10% rule’ has no solid evidence behind it.
“It only hurts when I run, so it’s probably just a niggle, right?” We hear a version of this from runners every week. Sometimes the answer is yes. Sometimes it is the first sign of something that needs weeks off the pavement, and guessing wrong costs you time either way.
How can I tell a niggle from something more serious?
A niggle is vague and spread out. It is often worst in the first few minutes, then settles as you warm up. It does not wake you at night.
These are general patterns, not a diagnosis. Two runners can feel the same thing and have different problems, which is why a hands-on assessment matters.
What does a bone stress injury actually feel like?
Think of a small, specific spot on a bone, often in the shin, foot or heel. You can press on it with one fingertip and find it. It tends to ache more as the run goes on, and it may hurt when you walk, hop or lie in bed.
The pattern to take seriously. Pain that builds through the run, is tender to press on the bone itself, and does not settle within a day of rest. That combination is a reason to stop and be checked.
How is tendon pain different?
Tendon pain tends to be stiff and sore first thing, or in the first steps of a run, then warm up and ease. It often sits in the Achilles, the back of the heel or the front of the knee, and it flares the next morning if you overdo it.
The good news is that tendons usually respond to loading, not rest. We cover exactly what that looks like in our guide to tendon pain and heavy slow resistance.
Who is more likely to get a bone stress injury?
Mileage matters, but it is not the whole story. A 2025 systematic review in the Journal of Sport Rehabilitation pooled 17 studies of 897 female off-road runners. It linked these injuries to older age, a previous bone stress injury, menstrual disruption, and lower intakes of calcium, vitamin D and calories. The authors say the evidence is limited and call for better studies.
A 2026 study of 172 elite Italian track and field athletes found a similar story. Endurance athletes had more leg and forefoot bone injuries than sprinters, and women with menstrual irregularities reported more of them. It was a retrospective questionnaire study, so it shows associations, not cause and effect.
Does this only affect women?
No. In the Italian study, sex made no difference to whether an athlete had a bone stress injury or how many they had. What differed was the pattern: for women, menstrual history and energy intake stood out.
For men and women alike, the common thread is the same: repeated impact without enough recovery or fuel.
When is it safe to start running again?
A 2024 scoping review in Sports Medicine screened 1,040 papers and included 50 on returning to running after a shin bone stress injury. It argues for clear criteria, not a fixed number of weeks.
The checklist it describes is practical: the sore spot is no longer tender, walking is pain-free, scans show healing when the injury is high risk, strength and hop tests look good, and the underlying causes have been dealt with. It also notes that the popular 10% rule lacks empirical support.
What does a proper comeback look like?
It starts with working out which of the three problems you have, then fixing what caused it. That might be training errors, calf and hip strength, or asking your GP about fuel and hormonal health.
Where it changes what we recommend, we can use force plates to compare your left and right leg when hopping, which is hard to judge by eye. This is the kind of work our team does every week with runners who want to get back to the start line.
If you are chasing tendon or knee pain too, see our page on running injuries physio in Logan and our gym-based rehab.
Daisy Hill Physio is at U4 11-13 Allamanda Dr, Daisy Hill QLD 4127 in Logan, Queensland, south of Brisbane (not Logan, Utah). To get your running sorted, book an appointment online or call 07 3209 2000 and tell reception what you are trying to get back to. We also see runners from across Logan and Slacks Creek. Email info@daisyhillphysio.com.au if you prefer.
This article is general information, not a diagnosis. Seek urgent medical care if you cannot weight-bear, have severe or night pain, a sudden snap, swelling or numbness, or feel unwell.
Reviewed by Ben Birchall, physiotherapist at Daisy Hill Physio, who works with endurance athletes and runners.
Sources: Stennett R, Scheer V, Kaulback K. Bone stress injury epidemiology and risk factors in female off-road runners: a systematic review. J Sport Rehabil 2025;34(5):470-483, doi 10.1123/jsr.2024-0288. Spinello G, et al. Bone stress injuries in elite runners: intrinsic and extrinsic risk factors in Italian track and field athletes. BMC Sports Sci Med Rehabil 2026;18, doi 10.1186/s13102-026-01639-3. Criteria and guidelines for returning to running following a tibial bone stress injury: a scoping review. Sports Med 2024, doi 10.1007/s40279-024-02051-y.



